http://webmail.libionline.net City of Beaumont Audit
 
California River Watch sent a Notice of Violations and Intent to File Suit Under the Clean Water Act to the City of Beaumont on December 12, 2014. The Report is 28 pages long. Below are excerpts from the Report. Read the Full Report Here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B3AGY65ivI_uNi1BRVloTkFPelNfajRrSlNUUWNUUGRENFJN/view?usp=sharing




Bottom Line: The City had a December 31st deadline to (1) initiate a discussion regarding the allegations and (2) set a date for a site visit. CalRiverWatch will have to stand in line behind the Beaumont-Cherry Valley Water District.




Excerpts From River Watch Report:

Beaumont’s aging collection system has historically experienced high Iil during wet weather. Sixty percent (60%) of the sewer lines were constructed prior to 1935. Forfy” percent (40%) were constructed prior to 2AV .

Structural defects which allow I/I into the sewer lines result in a buildup ofpressure which causes SSOs. Overflows caused by blockages and I/I result in the discharge of raw sewage into gutters, canals, and storm drains which are connected to adjacent surface waters - all waters of the United States.


As recorded in CIWQS Public SSO Reports, Beaumont’s collection system has experienced at least thirteen (13) SSOs between March 12,2009 and September 22,2011, with a combined volume of at least 353.727 gallons -221,1 60 gallons of which were reported as having reached surface waters.


Exfiltration caused by pipeline cracks and other structural defects in the collection system result in discharges to adjacent surface waters via underground hydrological connections. Beaumont’s internal reports indicate discharges to surface waters not reported to the California Integrated Water Quality System (“CIWQS”).

Because the entire system has not been adequately inspected by means of closed circuit television (“CCTV”), Beaumont has insufficient informationfor a significant portion of the collection system concerning its condition or the extent of exfiltration.

These sections of the system are old and in need of repair. Untreated sewage is discharged from cracks, displaced joints, eroded segments, etc., into ground water hydrologically connected to surface waters. Evidence indicates extensive exfiltration from lines within 200 feet of a surface water.


River Watch alleges that such discharges are continuous wherever aging, damaged, and/or structurally defective sewer lines in Beaumont’s collection system are located adjacent to surface waters, including tributaries of both the Salton Sea and the Santa Ana River Basin.

Surface waters and ground water become contaminated with fecal coliform, exposing people to pathogens. Chronic failures in the collection system pose a substantial threat to public health.

Studies tracing human markers specific to the human digestive system in surface waters adjacent to defective sewer lines have verified the contamination of the adjacent waters with untreated sewage.


Evidence of exfiltration can be found in mass balance data or “inflow and infiltration” (“I/I”) data, video inspection, and tests of waterways adjacent to sewer lines for nutrients, human pathogens and other human markers such as caffeine. Exfiltration from Beaumont’s collection system is a daily occurrence and a violation of Beaumont’s NPDES Permit and the CWA.


Discharges to Surface Waters.

River Watch’s expert believes that many of the SSOs reported by Beaumont as having been contained without reaching a surface water did in fact discharge to surface waters, and those reported as partially reaching surface waters did so in greater volume than stated.

The claim of full containment is further called into question by the fact that some of Beaumont’s SSO Reports state the estimated start time of the SSO as the time when the reporting party first noticed the SSO.

Studies have shown that most SSOs are noticed significantly after they have begun. Beaumont reports that some of the discharges reach a storm drain, but fails to determine the accurate amounts which reach a surface water.


Estimating Volume.

River Watch’s expert has also determined that Beaumont’s method for estimating flow rate also underestimates the volume of a SSO. Furthermore, a review of the service records calls into question Beaumont’s methodologies for determining the volume of SSOs captured. Beaumont is a permittee under the Statewide General Requirements for Sanitary Server Systems, Waste Discharge Requirements Order No. 2006-0003-DWQ (“Statewide WDR”) governing the operation of sanitary sewer systems.

The Statewide WDR requires that sewer system operators report SSOs to the CIWQS and include in that reporting an estimate of the volume of any spill, the volume recovered and the volume which reached a surface water.

Beaumont’s field reports generally do not indicate what method was used to estimate the total volume of the spill, which further calls into question the estimates of volume recovered and volume reaching surface waters. River Watch contends that Beaumont is grossly underestimatingthe incidence and volume of SSOs that reach surface waters.


Mitigating impacts.

Beaumont also fails to adequately mitigate the impacts of SSOs. The Statewide WDR mandates that the permittee shall take all feasible steps to contain and mitigate the impacts of a SSO. The EPA’s ‘Report to Congress on the Impacts of SSOs’ identifies SSOs as a major source of microbial pathogens and oxygen depleting substances. Numerous critical habitat areas exist within the areas of Beaumont’s SSOs.

There is no record of Beaumont performing any analysis of the impacts of SSOs on critical habitat of protected species under the ESA, nor any evaluation of the measures needed to restore water bodies designated as critical habitat from the impacts of SSOs.


One of the most important remedial measures is the performance of adequate sampling to determine the nature and the impact of the release. As Beaumont is severely underestimating SSOs which reach surface waters, Beaumont is also not conducting sampling on most SSOs. 



Order No. R8-2006-0003, IV. Effluent Limitations and Discharge Specifications,A. Effluent Limitations, 1. Final Effluent Limitations - Discharge Point No. M-001:

20 Effluent Discharges Exceeding the Permit Limit for Total Coliform: 
15 Effluent Discharges Exceeding the Permit Limit for Turbidity Daily Maximum: 
9 Effluent Discharges “not reaching” the permit limits for pH: 
1 Effluent Discharge Exceeding the Permit Limits for Chloroform 
Failure to Properly Monitor for Copper 
Failure to Properly Monitor for Mercury 
I Effluent Discharge on September 3, 2013 exceeding the Permit for Daily Average


River Watch has found nothing in the public record to demonstrate that Beaumont has monitored for and complied with these narrative standards. River Watch is understandably concerned regarding the effects of both surface and underground SSOs on critical habitat in and around tributary waters of both the Salton Sea and the Santa Ana River Basin.


3. The person or persons responsible for the alleged violation.


The entity responsible for the alleged violations identified in this Notice is the City of Beaumont, as the owner of the Beaumont Wastewater Treatment Plant No.1 and as the owner and operator of its associated collection system, and Urban Logic Consultants. Inc, the operator of the Beaumont Wastewater Treatment Plant No.l, collectively referred to as “Beaumont” in this Notice, as well as Beaumont’s employees responsible for compliance with Beaumont’s NPDES Permit.


The CWA specifically provides a 60-day “notice period” to promote resolution of disputes. River Watch strongly encourages Beaumont to contact River Watch within 20 days after receipt of this Notice Letter to: (1) initiate a discussion regarding the allegations detailed in this Notice, and(2) set a date for a site visit. In the absence of productive discussions to resolve this dispute, or receipt of additional information demonstrating that Beaumont is in compliance with the strict terms and conditions of its NPDES Permit, River Watch intends to file a citizen’s suit under CWA $ 505(a) when the 60-day notice period ends. 

 


Comments

It was curious for me to read this report! Thank you very much

Reply
12/03/2016 3:47am

Juggernox Your desires in mind. So, you’ve achieved a Juggernox marathon, ticked off the difficult udder and aced the a laugh run?
http://guidemesupplements.com/examination-juggernox/

Reply

It is just what I was looking for and quite thorough as well. Thanks for posting this, I saw a couple other similar posts but yours was the best so far. The ideas are strongly pointed out and clearly emphasized.

Reply
12/03/2016 3:51am

Fierce Male Enhancement Racing from a swim to a cycle to a run is a wonderful manner to interrupt up longer Fierce Male Enhancement distances, keeping your mind.
http://www.healthsupreviews.com/fierce-male-enhancement/

Reply
05/29/2015 6:31am

One of the most important remedial measures is the performance of adequate sampling to determine the nature and the impact of the release.

Reply


Loved to read your blog. I would like to suggest you that traffic show most people read blogs on Mondays. So it should encourage blogger to write new write ups over the weekend primarily.
Great post! Interesting information and cute writing style.
Regards

Reply
10/06/2015 4:11am

I used to be recommended this blog by means of my cousin. I am now not sure whether or not this put up is written by him as nobody else know such exact approximately my problem. You're incredible! Thanks!

Reply

After two years you finally got a new post. My congratulations!

Reply
11/05/2015 10:09am

The best lighting for smart people. Visit our site and ensure the adequacy of price .
Informative and interesting which we share with you so i think so it is very useful and knowledgeable. I would like to thank you for the efforts. I am tiring the same best work from me in the future as well. I'll use this information to provide research paper help.

Reply
11/22/2015 3:47am

Your thoughts and way of thinking is amazing. You found untold stories and information. I recognized about Indigenous Shamanism in general. Open your heart for writing service.

Reply
11/22/2015 9:47pm

Thank you for some of the articles. I find this is one of the very great article to read, I like this.

Reply

I used to be able to realize sensible data from your articles.

Reply

Your Blog design is elegant, your content classy. Appreciate for your post. I'm always interested in your articles.

Reply
11/22/2015 11:13pm

Good post. It is really helpful to us. Its give us lots of interest and pleasure. Its opportunity are so amazing and working so speedy. Its really a great article.

Reply

I'm glad I found your Blog today. This is really what I'm looking for. Thank you.

Reply
01/20/2016 6:30am

The article is very helpful, thank you very much

Reply

Report will be done in a second

Reply

I’m not that much of a online reader to be honest but your sites really nice, keep it up! I'll go ahead and bookmark your website to come back later on. All the best

Reply
02/04/2016 5:05pm

Never sleep and never fall we are young and we are free so we sing it loud and clear.

Reply
02/10/2016 1:25pm

thanks for the given info

Reply
09/12/2016 7:34pm

t but important zapatillas nike air max factor in your child’s continued musical success.

Reply

I love these!! I can't wait to try this on my own. Such a fabulous idea!!!

Reply

very interesting post

Reply
11/01/2016 9:50pm

Hi my contact no:- 9833972616 . My name is moinka dutta. I am 24 years old.1992. My height is 1.67. My locks are Blond. My eyes are black. My weight 56 kg Bra size:34C My nationality is Indian. I speak English,hindi. My Sexual orientation is Bisexual. My services is Mumbai escorts

Reply
11/01/2016 9:54pm

My name is Chahat Aarora. my contact no:- 9833972616. I am 23 years old.1993. My height is 1.68. My locks are Blond. My eyes are black. My weight 55 kg Bra size:34C My nationality is indian. I speak . English,hindi. My Sexual orientation is Bisexual. My services is Mumbai escorts

Reply
11/01/2016 10:00pm

Ahmedabad escorts I am 24 years old.1993. My height is 1.68. My locks are Blond. My eyes are black. My weight 54kg Bra size:34C My nationality is indian. I speak . English,hindi. My Sexual orientation is Bisexual.

Reply
11/01/2016 10:05pm

My name is Samiya. I am 21 years old.1994. My height is 1.68. My locks are Blond. My eyes are black. My weight 55 kg Bra size:34C My nationality is indian. I speak . English,hindi. My Sexual orientation is Bisexual. My services is Ahmedabad escorts

Reply
11/01/2016 10:08pm

My name is Chhoti I am 23 years old.1992. My height is 1.68. My locks are Blond. My eyes are black. My weight 53kg Bra size:34C My nationality is indian. I speak . English,hindi. My Sexual orientation is Bisexual. My services Ahmedabad escorts

Reply
11/01/2016 10:13pm

Ahmedabad escorts .I am 23 years old.1992. My height is 1.68. My locks are Blond. My eyes are black. My weight 51kg Bra size:34C My nationality is indian. I speak . English,hindi. My Sexual orientation is Bisexual. My services escorts in ahmedabad.

Reply

Experience the trustworthy and absolutely affordable turnkey interior design in Delhi, Noida, Gurgaon, India by Saffron Touch. We are one of the best turnkey interior contractor in Delhi providing wide ranges of interior designing and decoration services. Contact us today at 9050015646

Reply

We are thankful for Our propertybankpropmart are working brilliant and help with the interact of my clients. Call me :- +919873178059

Reply
01/17/2017 6:22am

Thanks for share knowledge

Reply
01/20/2017 4:42am

If you want to make your New Year fully enjoyable with kith and kens then you can get such admirable services for the better selections of Happy New Year 2018. We are always there to help you with the good items from our services with the assured ways.

Reply
02/01/2017 11:14pm

blackmart apk

Reply
03/01/2017 2:03am

Happy new year 2018 wishes are the best images that you can use to send as greetings to your near and dear ones to send a special message of happiness and prosperity that you wish for all your friends and relatives.

Reply
03/17/2017 12:14pm

Thanks a lot for sharing This is such a great web site.

Reply
03/31/2017 4:13am

Just want to comment on few general things, the website style is perfect, the written content is real great

Reply
03/31/2017 4:13am


Glad to chat your blog, I seem to be forward to more reliable articles and I think we all wish to thank so many good articles, blog to share with us.

Reply
04/04/2017 4:02am

It's a nice read. I like watching videos instead of reading articles though. Netflix offers good quality entertainment videosand documentaries without any commercials Contact Netflix

Reply

Nice article. It was a great reading. For any queries regarding Dell products contact Dell Customer Service Phone Number

Reply
04/04/2017 4:03am

nice one, It was a very nice article i like reading it. For any queries regarding HP products contact HP Phone Number

Reply

Good one. One of the best i ever read. For any queries regarding netgear networking products contact Netgear Support Phone Number

Reply
04/04/2017 4:03am

Good article. The words are quite inspiring. For any queries regarding roku contact Roku Contact

Reply
04/04/2017 4:07am

Good article. For any queries regarding linksys products contact Linksys Number

Reply

Inspiring article. For any queries regarding Cisco products contact Cisco Contact Centre Express

Reply

Thanks for the great post. I'm a big fan of your writing style. I will comeback and read all the other articles you posted.
Keep posting like this.

Reply
04/05/2017 2:21am

Nice work with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information which we all need, helpful information. I would like to thank you for the efforts you shown remarkable writing skill in this article

Reply

Thanks for the great post. I'm a big fan of your writing style. I will comeback and read all the other articles you posted.
Keep posting like this.
http://bahubali2torrentdownload.com

Reply

Nice work with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information which we all need, helpful information. I would like to thank you for the efforts you shown remarkable writing skill in this article
http://tubelighttorrentdownload.com

Reply
04/27/2017 4:06am

Thanks for sharing this interesting blog with us. My pleasure to being here on your blog.. I wanna come beck here for new post from your site.

<a href="http://www.happynewyear2018wallpapers.net/2017/04/hd-wallpapers-for-new-year-2018.html">New Year 2018 Hd Wallpapers</a>
<a href="http://www.happynewyear2018calendars.com/2017/04/indian-calendar-2018-for-indian-festival-and-india-holidays.html">Indian Calendar 2018</a>
<a href="http://www.happynewyear2018calendars.com/2017/04/download-2018-2019-2020-free-printable-calendars-templates-images-index-psd-files.html">Free Printable Calendar 2018</a>
<a href="http://happynewyear2019card.blogspot.com/2017/04/happy-new-year-2018-images-messages-wishes-cards-status-in-albanian.html">Happy New Year 2018 Messages Wishes in Albanian </a>
<a href="http://www.happynewyear0123456789.net/2017/03/happy-new-year-2019-vintage-images-graphics.html">Happy New Year 2019 Vintage Images</a>
<a href="http://www.happynewyear0123456789.net/2017/02/happy-new-year-whatsapp-and-facebook-2018-message-status-images.html"> Happy new year whatsapp and facebook 2018 message </a>
<a href="http://www.happynewyear0123456789.net/2017/04/top-100-download-new-year-images-2018-in-full-hd.html"> Download New Year Images 2018 in Full HD</a>
<a href="http://www.happynewyear0123456789.net/2017/04/happy-new-year-2018-best-new-year-whatsapp-facebook-messages-sms-to-send-happy-new-year-greetings.html">Best New Year WhatsApp & Facebook Messages</a>
<a href="http://happynewyearwallpapers2019.blogspot.com/2017/04/download-latest-hd-desktop-wallpapers-for-happy-new-year-2018.html"> Download latest HD Desktop Wallpapers for Happy new year 2018</a>
<a href="http://happynewyear2019greeting.blogspot.com/2017/04/new-year.html">Best collection of happy new year 2018 ecards </a>
<a href="http://www.happynewyear2018status.org/2017/04/best-happy-new-year-status-quotes-for-whatsapp-1-line-new-year-slogans-2018.html">Best Happy New Year Status Quotes for WhatsApp</a>
<a href="http://www.happynewyear2018status.com/2017/04/happy-new-year-images-messages-gifs.html">happy new year images messages 2018 in Chichewa</a>

Reply



Leave a Reply


Contact: libi@libionline.netCity of Beaumont Audit